The Innovation Deficit: Why Canadian Startups Stall Before Scaling

The Scale-Up Gap

Canada ranks 8th globally for startup creation but 26th for scale-up success, according to the Global Innovation Index. Only 5 % of tech firms surpass 100 employees.

MetricCanadaU.S.OECD Avg.Source
Business R&D (% of GDP)0.92.11.6OECD MSTI
Venture Capital ($ bn, 2024)10.2216PitchBook
Firms >100 employees (% of total)4.8 %8.5 %Statistics Canada

Structural Issues

  • Fragmented venture capital ecosystem.
  • Weak procurement channels between startups and large firms.
  • Conservative risk culture in both government and corporates.

Momentum Builders

Federal IP Strategy 2.0 and the new National Innovation Fund ($3 billion) could catalyze later-stage financing — if matched by corporate demand.

What Leaders Can Do

  1. Act as early adopters. Pilot Canadian tech within supply chains.
  2. Form innovation consortia. Co-invest in R&D with smaller firms and universities.
  3. Align incentives. Tie procurement and sustainability KPIs to domestic innovation sourcing.
  4. Champion export readiness. Mentor scale-ups on governance and capital access abroad.

Arcus Insight: Innovation isn’t policy; it’s procurement. When Canada’s largest 500 firms allocate 1 % of spend to domestic innovators, GDP could rise by $30 billion within five years.